Skip to main content
Live
✦ SportSignals+ just now
Value SmartBetsNEW Props Predictions Live My Bets Alerts
The Dugoutanalysis· 4 min read

Gary Neville's 'Disgusting' Verdict Exposes The Real Problem Pochettino Must Fix At Manchester United

Neville says Michael Carrick was taking training in Manchester while executives sealed Mauricio Pochettino's arrival in Monaco, and warns the new head coach inherits the same dysfunction that sank his predecessor.

AI-generated editorial illustration for "Gary Neville's 'Disgusting' Verdict Exposes The Real Problem Pochettino Must Fix At Manchester United".
AI-generated editorial illustration for "Gary Neville's 'Disgusting' Verdict Exposes The Real Problem Pochettino Must Fix At Manchester United". · SportSignals AI-generated editorial illustration · AI-generated editorial illustration

By David Adams, Sports AnalystAI-assisted

Gary Neville has called Manchester United's handling of Michael Carrick's sacking "disgusting", revealing that club executives were in Monaco finalising terms with Mauricio Pochettino while Carrick was still taking training sessions back at the club's Carrington base, unaware his position had already been settled according to Sky Sports.

The timeline matters. Carrick was sacked this week after three wins from his last 15 matches left United in the relegation zone, and Neville's anger is directed less at the decision itself than at the manner of it. For a club that employed Carrick with distinction as a player, the optics of negotiating his successor while he ran a session for players who may already have known his fate is, in Neville's words, a reflection of "poor leadership" at the top of the club.

Neville: 'They watched him resign on the pitch'

Neville's criticism of United's decision-making did not start this week. He has argued since United's 3-0 defeat to Bournemouth that Carrick's exit should have been triggered there and then, pointing to the head coach's lap of the pitch afterwards as a de facto resignation that the club failed to act on.

Bournemouth and the goodbye lap that should have ended it

"I think after the Bournemouth game I said at the time that Manchester United effectively watched Michael Carrick resign on the pitch at the end of the game with that lap around, that wave goodbye. I think he was expecting it to come at that point and they were indecisive," Neville said on Sky Sports News.

He went further, describing United's inertia in the fortnight that followed as symptomatic of a wider malaise.

"They obviously felt that they might be able to get to the international break and there could be some sort of pick-up in results, but it's been a difficult two weeks. Indecision, lack of authority, just basically really poor leadership," he added, via Sky Sports.

From League Cup celebration to relegation zone

The collapse is striking in its speed. Carrick was only handed a permanent two-year contract in the summer after an impressive caretaker spell following Ruben Amorim's exit, winning 12 of 17 matches and securing Champions League qualification. That form has since inverted almost completely, with United's current league position the reason the club moved, even if Neville's issue is squarely with how they moved.

Monaco deal-making while Carrick trained the team

The image of United's hierarchy conducting business in Monaco while Carrick worked with the first team in Manchester is, for Neville, the clearest evidence yet of a club that treats its own staff as an afterthought. He was blunt about how that would be judged outside football.

Executives abroad, head coach oblivious in Manchester

"In the last 24-48 hours it's been spectacularly bad to be in Monaco as an executive and an owner whilst your manager, who's a club legend, is taking training on the pitch and simultaneously approaching the US Soccer Federation to approach Mauricio Pochettino," Neville said. "It's just quite simply disgusting. That falls well below the standard of what you would expect in any other business, in any other industry. It would be constructive dismissal and you'd be getting sued," he told Sky Sports.

That account is corroborated by ESPN, which reported that Carrick was set to take training again on Wednesday while waiting for news on his future, with the club already in contact with Pochettino. The convergence of two independent accounts, Sky Sports' and ESPN's, leaves little ambiguity about the sequencing: the pursuit of a replacement was running in parallel with Carrick's day job, not after it ended.

What the reporting agrees, and where it differs

There is a subtle gap between outlets on exactly how far along the Pochettino deal is. Sky Sports describes a "full agreement in principle" with talks between United and the US Soccer Federation at the paperwork and regulatory stage. ESPN's later reporting goes a step further, stating Pochettino has agreed to become the next United manager, with an announcement expected on Friday. The discrepancy is one of degree rather than substance: both agree a deal is effectively done, they differ only on whether it has crossed from principle into formal agreement. Either way, the paperwork with US Soccer is the final administrative hurdle before confirmation, not a genuine obstacle to the move.

Why Pochettino's biggest battle will be off the pitch

Neville's sharpest point was not really about Carrick at all. It was a warning to Pochettino that the job he is walking into has a structural problem that no head coach, however gifted, can solve alone from the touchline.

Neville's recruitment demand

Neville insisted Pochettino must be handed genuine control of recruitment and backed with significant investment if he is to avoid Carrick's fate. The subtext is unmistakable: United have now sacked multiple managers in quick succession, and each one inherited a squad shaped by decisions he did not make. If Pochettino arrives with the same lack of authority over transfers that undermined his predecessors, his honeymoon period will be short, regardless of how the appointment is dressed up publicly.

The USMNT paperwork still outstanding

Pochettino's own trajectory towards Old Trafford had been building for weeks. ESPN reported in early November that Pochettino had spoken of his desire to return to Europe, setting up the dilemma between his USMNT role and a return to the Premier League. That he is now the overwhelming favourite to be confirmed within days shows how quickly that dilemma resolved once United moved.

What happens next

An announcement confirming Pochettino as United's new head coach is expected imminently, with ESPN's sources pointing to Friday as the likely date once the regulatory processes with US Soccer are completed. For Carrick, there will be no second chance to control the narrative of his exit; the club has already moved on in every sense but the formal one.

The more consequential question is the one Neville has posed to United's ownership rather than to Pochettino himself. Will the new head coach be given the recruitment authority that successive predecessors were denied, or will he simply become the next manager absorbing the consequences of decisions made above him? Judged by the Monaco optics alone, there is little evidence yet that the hierarchy has changed, only the name in the dugout.

Bettors and fans assessing Pochettino's prospects should treat the appointment with caution rather than optimism. The pattern Neville describes, indecision, poor communication, and executives operating at a remove from the football department, has outlasted several managers already. Unless that changes, Pochettino's arrival risks being remembered not as the fix United needed, but as the same mistake repeated in new clothes.

SportSignals is an independent publication. Views expressed are our own.

Sources

  1. Secondary sourceIndependent of the subject
    Neville 'disgusted' at Man Utd's treatment of Carrick

    Sky Sports Football · Sky Sports Football · Published 12 Nov 2026

    Supports: Gary Neville has branded Manchester United's handling of Michael Carrick's sacking 'disgusting', revealing that club executives were in Monaco finalising a deal with Mauricio Pochettino while Carrick was still taking training sessions back in Manchester, unaware his fate had already been sealed.

Open the reporting used for this article. Material quotes and figures should also carry an inline citation in the article body.

How this article was produced

AI assisted research and drafting. David Adams checked the sources and quotations, edited the article and approved this exact version for publication.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why did Gary Neville call Manchester United's treatment of Michael Carrick disgusting?

Neville said club executives were in Monaco finalising terms with Mauricio Pochettino while Carrick was still training the Manchester United squad, unaware his position had already been settled. He described this as a reflection of poor leadership and a lack of authority at the top of the club.

Why was Michael Carrick sacked by Manchester United?

Carrick was sacked after winning just three of his last 15 matches, a run that left United in the relegation zone. Neville argued the club should have acted sooner, pointing to Carrick's farewell lap after the 3-0 defeat to Bournemouth as a de facto resignation.

What problem must Mauricio Pochettino fix at Manchester United?

According to Neville, Pochettino must address the club's recruitment process and lack of internal authority, issues that led to Carrick's chaotic exit. Neville warns that without fixing this dysfunction, Pochettino risks suffering the same fate.