Tuchel's Snub of Cole Palmer Exposes a Trust Problem, Not a Patriotism Problem
Morgan Rogers insists Cole Palmer still wants to play for England, but Thomas Tuchel's flat response suggests the issue was never really about desire.

By David Adams, Sports AnalystAI-assisted
Morgan Rogers has publicly dismissed the idea that his Chelsea team-mate Cole Palmer does not want to play for England, calling the suggestion "a lie" and "nonsense" after Palmer was omitted from Thomas Tuchel's squad for the Nations League double-header against Croatia and Spain for the second camp running Sky Sports reports.
The defence was heartfelt. Tuchel's reply to it was anything but. When asked about Rogers' comments after England's 2-1 win over Croatia on Thursday, the England manager offered a notably flat response, praising Rogers' own commitment rather than addressing Palmer's situation directly. That contrast, Rogers' emotional loyalty against Tuchel's transactional detachment, is the real story here.
Why Palmer was left out again, and what Tuchel said in September
Palmer, 24, did not make England's squad for last summer's World Cup, and his absence from the current Nations League fixtures with Croatia and Spain marks the second consecutive camp he has missed. He withdrew from September's internationals through injury, a decision that prompted an unusually pointed response from his manager at the time.
The September ultimatum
Tuchel said in September that Palmer "misses too many opportunities to impress him" following that withdrawal, according to Sky Sports. It was a rare, public airing of frustration from a manager towards one of his most gifted attacking players, and it set the tone for everything that has followed.
Sky Sports News' Rob Dorsett framed the latest omission as confirmation of that stance, writing that Tuchel "doesn't doubt his ability" but feels Palmer "has not done enough to prove" he has the presence, commitment and humility the manager demands, as reported by Sky Sports.
Form is not the issue
Whatever is driving the exclusion, it is not a dip in output. Palmer has contributed five goals and three assists in 12 games in all competitions for Chelsea this season, numbers that outstrip several players currently preferred ahead of him in Tuchel's squad. According to Dorsett's analysis for Sky Sports, Palmer's eight goal involvements in 11 matches compare favourably with both Eberechi Eze and Morgan Gibbs-White, who have both been selected.
- Palmer has played just three matches under Tuchel since the German took charge in January 2025.
- He has been unavailable through injury five times during that period.
- On two of those occasions he was named in the squad before withdrawing.
Rogers' defence: 'It's a lie' and what it reveals about the dressing room
Rogers, who scored the opening goal in England's 2-1 win over Croatia while Harry Kane added a penalty on his record-breaking 126th appearance, spoke from a position of current form and standing inside the camp. His comments carry weight precisely because he has nothing to gain from defending an absent team-mate other than loyalty.
"It's a lie. He wants to be here. He wanted to get called up and he wanted to come and represent his country as he always has done. People just see it as news and say the easy thing."
Morgan Rogers, speaking to BBC Radio 5 Live, as reported by BBC Sport
Managing injuries, not motivation
Rogers was explicit that Palmer's absences are about physical management rather than reluctance. "We all know he had a difficult year last year with injuries and I know personally he's been managing them injuries ever since," he said, adding that Palmer "was in quite a low place with his injuries last year and didn't feel 100 per cent himself on the pitch" Sky Sports reports.
Both Sky Sports and the BBC's account carry near-identical quotes from Rogers, including his use of the word "nonsense" to describe the narrative around Palmer. The two outlets differ only in emphasis, with the BBC leading on Rogers' goal against Croatia and Sky Sports placing greater weight on Tuchel's September comments, but neither contradicts the other on the substance of what Rogers said or why he said it.
Tuchel's cool response shows this is about trust, not patriotism
If Rogers' intervention was designed to settle the matter, Tuchel's reply did the opposite. Asked directly about his team-mate's comments, the England manager offered little beyond a shrug dressed in diplomacy.
'That's what matters'
"It's totally fine. He's his team-mate and friend, so why wouldn't he? I was very happy with the commitment of Morgan Rogers and that's what matters."
Thomas Tuchel, post-match press conference, as reported by Sky Sports
Notice what Tuchel did not say. He did not deny the premise, defend Palmer's character, or offer any sign that the relationship is being repaired. Instead he pivoted straight to praising Rogers, the player who is actually delivering for him on the pitch. That is the language of a manager drawing a line under the issue rather than resolving it.
This fits the wider pattern Tuchel has established since taking charge in January 2025. Chelsea head coach Xabi Alonso was also asked about Palmer's England situation and chose to swerve the question entirely, according to Sky Sports, a sign that even those closest to Palmer are wary of wading into a dispute that has become less about football and more about trust.
What happens next
Nothing here suggests an imminent thaw. Tuchel's language points to a manager who has set conditions around presence, commitment and humility, and who believes Palmer has not met them regardless of his club output. Unless that changes, further call-ups may hinge less on goals and assists at Chelsea and more on whether Palmer can convince his manager he is fully invested in the international set-up.
For Chelsea, the priority is simpler: keep Palmer healthy and firing domestically, where his five goals and three assists in 12 games this season are needed regardless of his England status. For England bettors and squad-depth watchers, Palmer's continued absence thins out attacking options behind players like Eze and Gibbs-White, even as his underlying numbers suggest he remains one of the country's most dangerous forwards.
The next natural flashpoint will be the March squad announcement ahead of the World Cup cycle's business end. If Palmer is fit, in form, and still left out, Tuchel's "that's what matters" comment will look less like a passing remark and more like a manager who has already made up his mind.
SportSignals is an independent publication. Views expressed are our own.
Sources
- Secondary sourceIndependent of the subject'It's a lie! Palmer wants to play for England, says Rogers
Sky Sports Football · Sky Sports Football · Published 13 Nov 2026
Supports: Morgan Rogers has publicly rejected the growing narrative that Cole Palmer doesn't want to play for England, calling it 'a lie' and 'nonsense' after Palmer was left out of Thomas Tuchel's squad for the Croatia and Spain Nations League fixtures for the second camp running.
Open the reporting used for this article. Material quotes and figures should also carry an inline citation in the article body.
How this article was produced
AI assisted research and drafting. David Adams checked the sources and quotations, edited the article and approved this exact version for publication.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why did Thomas Tuchel leave Cole Palmer out of the England squad?
Tuchel feels Palmer has not shown enough presence, commitment and humility to warrant selection, following criticism in September that Palmer 'misses too many opportunities to impress him'. It is Palmer's second consecutive omission from an England camp, with Tuchel citing trust rather than form or ability.
Does Cole Palmer not want to play for England?
Chelsea team-mate Morgan Rogers has publicly called that suggestion 'a lie' and 'nonsense'. Tuchel himself did not address the claim directly when asked, instead praising Rogers' own commitment.
How has Cole Palmer been performing for Chelsea this season?
Palmer has scored five goals and provided three assists in 12 games in all competitions for Chelsea this season. His eight goal involvements in 11 matches outstrip squad members Eberechi Eze and Morgan Gibbs-White, who were both selected by Tuchel.

