Berrada's Defence of Manchester United's Coaching Chaos Doesn't Survive Contact With the Facts
The United chief executive admits fan anger is partly justified but insists some criticism has 'crossed a line', even as his own players publicly contradict the club's version of events

By David Adams, Sports AnalystAI-assisted
Manchester United chief executive Omar Berrada has broken cover to defend the club's decision to sack Michael Carrick after barely four months in charge, replacing him with Mauricio Pochettino while United sit 18th in the Premier League, inside the relegation zone. In an exclusive interview with Sky Sports, Berrada admitted some supporter criticism of the hierarchy is fair, but said some of it has "crossed a line".
It is a carefully pitched line designed to project accountability without actually conceding structural failure. But the problem for Berrada is that the pattern now speaks louder than the PR.
A Familiar Pattern: United's Third Mid-Season Coaching Change in Three Years
This is the third consecutive season United have sacked a head coach mid-campaign. Erik ten Hag went in 2024-25, replaced by Ruben Amorim after the club initially chose to stick with him despite reportedly speaking to other candidates. Carrick has now suffered an almost identical fate, dismissed during the November international break having been retained through a chaotic summer transfer window, only for United to U-turn within months exactly as they did twelve months earlier.
Same Decision, Same Timing, Same Excuse
Berrada frames the Carrick sacking as a necessary correction. "It's clear, it's not good enough, not acceptable, and that's why we've made the change that we've made, so that we can move forward," he told Sky Sports.
What he does not address directly is why the same failure mode, backing a manager through a transfer window and then abandoning him weeks into the season, has now happened twice running. That is not a managerial problem. It is a recruitment and planning problem sitting above the dugout.
Players Are Already Saying What Berrada Won't
Defender Lisandro Martinez has publicly criticised technical director Jason Wilcox for failing to prepare the squad adequately in the transfer window, comments that followed United's Champions League defeat to Atletico Madrid, as reported by Sky Sports. Captain Bruno Fernandes has separately criticised Carrick's coaching staff and their methods. Both interventions came from senior dressing-room figures, not disgruntled outsiders, and both point squarely at the structures Berrada now insists are sound.
Berrada's Defence, and Where He Draws the Line on Criticism
Asked whether it has been difficult watching fans turn on the hierarchy, Berrada did not dodge the question entirely.
"It is. I'm not going to lie. But let's be clear, we're not the protagonists. This is not about the individuals, this is about the club... Being in this position comes naturally with the criticism and the scrutiny that we're going to get. We accept it, some of it is fair, some of it does cross the line."
That quote, carried by both Sky Sports and BBC Sport, is the clearest admission yet from United's leadership that the fan backlash has substance. Both outlets agree on the substance of the remarks and the wider context of the interview, with the BBC's framing, "fan criticism has gone too far at times", echoing Sky's reporting of the "crossed a line" phrasing almost word for word.
The 'Crossed a Line' Framing Deserves Scrutiny
What neither Berrada nor the surrounding coverage specifies is where, exactly, legitimate criticism ends and the illegitimate kind begins. That ambiguity is doing a lot of work. Invoking social media negativity, which Berrada also referenced in the interview, is a familiar corporate deflection when criticism gets uncomfortably close to the truth: it allows a leadership team to acknowledge failure in the abstract while discrediting the loudest, most specific voices making the case against them.
Berrada's interview also touched on several other live issues at Old Trafford, underlining a club under pressure on multiple fronts simultaneously:
- Captain Bruno Fernandes' ongoing contract talks
- The departure of JJ Gabriel from the club
- Berrada's own involvement in the unrelated Manchester City charges case
- Defence of United's recent transfer activity, which he insists has strengthened the squad despite widespread criticism
Taken together, it is a picture of a chief executive fighting fires on several fronts at once, while insisting the foundations underneath are solid.
Pochettino's Liverpool Test and the Road Back from 18th
Berrada's optimism now rests almost entirely on Pochettino. "The foundations are there. I am convinced that we are heading in the right direction," he said, describing the "buzz" the Argentine has already brought to the building.
No Margin for a Slow Start
That conviction gets its first real examination this Sunday, when Pochettino takes charge of his maiden game away at Liverpool, live on Sky Sports. There is no gentle introduction on offer: a trip to Anfield against United's fiercest rivals, with the club sitting in the relegation zone, is as unforgiving a first fixture as English football can produce.
A positive result would hand Berrada's narrative some short-term credibility. A heavy defeat would instantly reopen every question his interview was designed to close down, not least whether Pochettino was hired as a genuine long-term solution or simply the next name in a rotating door that has now spun three times in three years.
What Happens Next
United's immediate priority is survival, and that begins at Anfield this weekend. A poor result would pile further pressure on a leadership team already fielding public criticism from two of its own senior players, Martinez and Fernandes, over recruitment and coaching standards.
Beyond Sunday, the bigger question is structural rather than tactical. Berrada can talk about foundations and sustained growth, but until United break the pattern of appointing, backing, then abruptly discarding head coaches within a single transfer cycle, fans have every reason to treat his reassurances with scepticism.
Fernandes' contract situation and the fallout from the Manchester City charges case will also continue to run alongside the on-pitch crisis, giving Old Trafford little respite from scrutiny even if results improve under Pochettino.
SportSignals is an independent publication. Views expressed are our own.
Sources
- Secondary sourceIndependent of the subjectBerrada on Carrick, Poch, defending club leadership and transfers
Sky Sports Football · Sky Sports Football · Published 20 Nov 2026
Supports: Manchester United CEO Omar Berrada has broken cover to defend the club's decision-making - including sacking Michael Carrick for Mauricio Pochettino - while admitting some fan criticism of the leadership is fair, but insisting some has 'crossed a line', all with United sitting 18th in the Premier League.
Open the reporting used for this article. Material quotes and figures should also carry an inline citation in the article body.
How this article was produced
AI assisted research and drafting. David Adams checked the sources and quotations, edited the article and approved this exact version for publication.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why did Manchester United sack Michael Carrick?
Manchester United sacked Michael Carrick during the November international break after just four months in charge, with the club sitting 18th in the Premier League. He was replaced by Mauricio Pochettino as part of what CEO Omar Berrada called a necessary correction.
What did Omar Berrada say about Manchester United's coaching changes?
Berrada told Sky Sports that fan criticism of the club hierarchy is partly fair but insisted some of it has 'crossed a line'. He defended the sacking as necessary to help the club 'move forward', without addressing why the same pattern repeated from the previous season.
Have Manchester United players criticised the club's structure?
Yes, defender Lisandro Martinez publicly criticised technical director Jason Wilcox over transfer window preparation after the Atletico Madrid defeat. Captain Bruno Fernandes has separately criticised Carrick's coaching staff and their methods.
More News
The DugoutPochettino's Culture Talk Won't Save Manchester United, Only Points Will
Mauricio Pochettino says fixing Manchester United's culture is his top priority, but with the club 18th in the table and facing Liverpool within days, a leaky defence and the Bruno Fernandes captaincy question will prove a far quicker test than any philosophy.

Transfer CentreManchester United's January War Chest Can't Hide a Summer Recruitment Failure
Manchester United's board will financially back Mauricio Pochettino in January with a left-back, centre-back and forward on the agenda, but the targets, including Calvin Bassey and Jarrad Branthwaite, were reportedly identified under sacked predecessor Michael Carrick, raising questions about whose rebuild this really is.

The DugoutPochettino's Guardiola Endorsement Can't Disguise the Size of the Job He Leaves Behind
Mauricio Pochettino used his farewell USA press conference to urge Pep Guardiola to take the USMNT job, but with no formal US Soccer contact made, the comment looks more like a convenient exit line than a succession plan, especially as Pochettino himself departs a World Cup host nation for a Manchester United side in the relegation zone.

